A Bessemer Renter Asked: “Should I Rekey or Fully Replace My Locks After Moving Into a Used Apartment?”

Last updated: July 17, 2026

If you’re a new renter in Bessemer moving into a used apartment, rekeying is typically the right choice and costs less than a full replacement. Full replacement is only necessary if the existing locks are damaged, outdated, or incompatible with your security needs. Pricing for either job is quoted on the phone before we dispatch a locksmith, so you know the cost before anyone shows up. A quick locksmith inspection answers this question in minutes.

The Short Answer: Rekey First, Replace Only If Needed

Rekeying is the smarter, more affordable choice for 95% of renters moving into used apartments in Bessemer. When a locksmith rekeys your front door, they remove the cylinder and replace the internal pins so that the old keys no longer fit – only your new key works. The lock body itself stays in place. It’s a quick job, and pricing is quoted on the phone before we ever come out.

Full replacement – removing the old lock entirely and installing a brand-new one (like a Schlage or Yale) – costs more and takes longer. You only need replacement if the existing lock is broken, rusted, loose, incompatible with a new door, or so old that parts are no longer available.

Before you decide anything, have a licensed locksmith inspect your apartment’s existing locks at no charge. That conversation usually settles the question quickly.

The Full Answer: When to Rekey, When to Replace

Why Rekeying Is the Standard Choice for Renters

Rekeying solves the core problem: you don’t know who has copies of the old keys. The previous tenant, a family member, maintenance staff, or even a locksmith might hold duplicates. Rekeying guarantees that none of those old keys will open your door ever again.

The process is simple. A locksmith removes the cylinder (the part that holds the key), takes out five or six spring-loaded pins, and inserts a new set of pins that only match your new key. The lock mechanism, strike plate, and door hardware all stay unchanged. Your door looks exactly the same when the job is done.

“In our experience, 90% of renters moving into used apartments in Bessemer only need a rekey. The existing locks work fine; they just need to be secured to that renter’s keys. Replacement is rarer and usually only comes up if the lock is genuinely damaged or if the renter wants to upgrade to a premium grade lock for personal peace of mind.” – 205 Locksmith Services Team

Rekeying is also reversible in one important way: if you move out, the landlord can rekey it again for the next tenant, rather than throwing away an entire working lock. That sustainability matters for property managers who manage three or four buildings on Lakeshore or across Bessemer.

When Full Replacement Becomes Necessary

Replacement is the right call when the existing lock shows one or more of these red flags:

• Visible damage: the lock is dented, rusted, or corroded (common in humid Bessemer summers)
• Loose or broken mechanism: the key turns sluggishly, sticks, or the lock jiggles in the door
• Unknown lock type: the lock is so old or generic that a locksmith cannot service it or obtain pins for rekeying
• Incompatible knob or deadbolt: you want to upgrade to a smart lock or high-security-grade Medeco cylinder, which may require new hardware
• Previous break-in or tampering: if the lock shows signs of forced entry, replacement gives you peace of mind that it’s secure

Most apartment locks in Bessemer are standard brass or chrome-plated keyed knobs or deadbolts installed 5-15 years ago. These rekey quickly and reliably. If the lock is solid and the mechanism turns freely, rekeying is almost always the smarter, faster, cheaper option.

Cost Comparison: Rekey vs. Replace

For a typical Bessemer apartment with a front door keyed knob and a deadbolt, rekeying both locks costs noticeably less than replacing both, and pricing for either job is quoted on the phone before we dispatch a locksmith. Rekeying is also faster, so you regain full access to your apartment sooner than you would waiting on a full replacement job.

Check Your Lease: Who Pays?

Before you call a locksmith, review your lease. In many Alabama rental agreements, the landlord is responsible for maintaining the locks and ensuring that each new tenant receives sole possession of the keys. Some landlords automatically rekey as part of the move-in process and include the cost in rent or a one-time move-in fee.

Other leases specify that renters can request a rekey at their own expense. A few landlords will split the cost. Before paying out of pocket, contact your landlord or property manager in writing (email is best) and ask: “Who is responsible for rekeying the front door lock before I move in?” A clear answer now saves a dispute later.

If the landlord declines to pay, call ahead and get a straight answer on cost. Pricing for a professional rekey is quoted on the phone before anyone is dispatched, so there are no surprises. It’s a one-time cost for the peace of mind that you, and only you, have the keys to your apartment.

The Inspection Visit: What to Expect

A professional locksmith will look over your locks and give you a clear recommendation on the spot. They’ll test the key turn, check for play in the mechanism, and note the lock brand and condition. A Schlage or Yale lock that turns smoothly and shows no wear is almost always a good candidate for rekeying. A lock with rust, a stuck key, or visible damage is a replacement candidate.

Licensed locksmiths in Bessemer typically offer free consultations and written estimates. Call before committing to anything, and get the full price over the phone. Many shops, including 205 Locksmith Services, handle both rekeying and replacement on the same visit if you decide mid-job that an upgrade makes sense.

Related Question We Often Hear

When the Answer Is Different

If your apartment is in a newer high-rise building in Bessemer with a master key system: You may not have the authority to rekey or replace locks. Building management may control master access and have rules about modifications. Verify with management before hiring a locksmith.

If you want a smart lock (keypad, fingerprint, or Bluetooth): Replacement is mandatory. Smart locks require new hardware and electrical wiring that rekeying cannot accommodate. Pricing for a smart lock installation is quoted on the phone before dispatch. Check your lease first – some landlords prohibit smart locks without written permission.

If the lock was recently broken or tampered with: Replacement is worth the extra cost to ensure the lock is secure and hasn’t been compromised. You can’t inspect internal damage visually; a locksmith can, and they’ll advise accordingly.

If you’re moving into a shared corridor with other renters (townhouse or duplex): Rekey the deadbolt at minimum. The keyed knob is less critical if the deadbolt is the primary entry point. Ask the locksmith which lock matters most for security and rekey that one first.

FAQ: Your Rekeying and Replacement Questions Answered

205 Locksmith Services

Professional locksmith service available 24/7 across Alabama. Mobile across Greater Birmingham around the clock, licensed technicians, and an honest arrival picture and price given to you on the phone.

Get Your Free Rekey Inspection in Bessemer →